Founders, non-founders and fake founders
One thing that keeps living rent-free in my head since Jensen Huang got pushed out of Nvidia is this fundamental split between three very different breeds of people in companies: founders, non-founders, and fake founders.
Founders are creators. They are the people who know how to start with nothing but a blank sheet of paper and turn it into something that exists. Huang started Nvidia in a Denny's restaurant, Jobs started Apple in a garage. These stories have been romanticized to death, but they still capture something true: founders know how to create a business out of thin air. They're more akin to artists than to conventional executives.
Non-founders are, paradoxically, the founders' best friends. They are the people who jump on an idea and transform it from a vision into something that actually exists. They can be engineers, employees, customers, suppliers, or even (sometimes) investors. Their genius lies in execution, and I think this ability is massively overlooked and underpriced in our ecosystem.
Finally, there are the fake founders. They look like founders but they are not: they are heirs, people living off their assets. They derive their power from a position they didn’t create, yet act as if they did. They can be CEOs who expanded a business from the comfort of an existing business unit. They can be politicians who sold themselves to whatever trend would get them elected. They can be financiers who think they know better because they sit on a mountain of cash.
If you ask anyone, they will probably think of society's divide in terms of non-founders vs. founders. Which is understandable to some extent: founders usually make an order of magnitude more than employees. But if you look at the reasons why, it’s mostly because of bad incentives designed by fake founders: investors who try to squeeze employees out, politicians who don’t favor stock options…
Hence, I believe this is wrong: the real divide is founders and non-founders vs. fake founders. We've become so obsessed with the divide between capital and labor that we've completely missed the people who actually benefit from keeping those two groups opposed.
Which leads me to the real problem: the West (Europe being worse than the US) has shifted from a society of builders (founders) to a society of bureaucrats (fake founders). Fake founders are everywhere. They are the politicians who decide how much you can make, they’re the compliance department sitting on the board next to the engineering department, they’re the journalists who turn the smallest piece of gossip into a massive scandal.
The common denominator of fake founders is that they mistake the authority they inherited for legitimacy. They live in the commentariat, where having an opinion is valued more than actually doing things. This often translates into an inordinate number of rules being imposed. Because it creates a framework that can justify the non-founder’s lack of creativity and vision.
Except that creativity, vision, and outside-the-box thinking are what make our societies progress. We have gone from building the Grand Palais and the General Electric Building to building grey, uninspired boxes. We have gone from going to the Moon to mocking a man’s aspiration to go to Mars. Our society is sick with pessimism and despair.
All this because fake founders have (sometimes with good intentions) trapped us in a society straitjacketed by rules and morality. As a result, the West, the land of the free, the birthplace of the Enlightenment, has grown darker and locked itself into a form of cynicism, while countries that are far less free on paper, like China, are where the future is being invented.
My worldview changed significantly when I signed up for Xiaohongshu and Weibo and during my trips to China. Here is a society that’s completely unfree but still has so much creativity and so many innovative solutions to problems. Why? Because it’s a nation of engineers. In 2020, engineering and computer science accounted for 33% of university degrees in China, compared with just 13% in the US.
Until very recently, the tech industry was pretty safe from fake founders. The ecosystem rewarded risk-taking, pushed out fakers, and favored builders. But success attracts attention, and as tech grew, so did the number of people who wanted to have a say in it without actually building anything. The bureaucrats, the commentators, and the professional managers gradually found their way in.
And tech is now starting to suffer from the same problems as the rest of the West. Sure, there are still Elon Musks and Mark Zuckerbergs out there. But I think our ecosystem should be extremely careful not to sink into the commentariat. We need to keep respecting builders. Excelsior!